Simon Says: Does a sitting tenant rights outweigh that of landlord’s spouse?

Published
05/24/2017 by

This is the thirteenth in a weekly series of legal advice provided in a short and entertaining story format.

 

This week's areas of Interest: Landlord Tenant Disputes

 

This week's keywords: Contract, Tenancy Law, Limitations on Right of First Refusal

 

 

Simon Says: Does a sitting tenant rights outweigh that of landlord’s spouse? 

 

 

Jack, the CEO of Jack Enterprises Ltd, recently fell in love with a Victoria Secrets model. As a wedding gift, he decided to give her one of his mansions, which was currently leased to Alex, as a gift.

 

However, Jill, his new bride, didn’t want to accept such a generous gift. She didn’t like taking things without earning it. After a series of convincing, she finally agreed to pay a low price of 1 million for the three-story mansion. A sale and purchase agreement was made accordingly.

 

Jack knew that Alex’s lease was about to expire, so he went over to talk to him, to ask him to start finding a new mansion. After all, the lessee Alex had lived there for 10 years already. It seemed too brutal to just kick him out without a three months’ notice.

 

However, Alex really loved that mansion as it gave him a complete view of the beach. He had tried to make Jack sell it for a billion times, without success.

 

‘I have to sell it to my wife. It would be her new maiden house. Please understand this. I can rent you another mansion.’ Jack said.

 

‘I have the right of first refusal as I am your tenant. Whatever price your wife pays, I’ll pay the same. In cash.’ Alex argued.

 

Jack replied, ‘Come on. I’ll sell another mansion to you. One of your picking. At a discount.’

 

Refusing to accept the offer, Alex said, ‘No. It has to be this mansion. I am not moving out of it.’

 

So can Alex exercise his right and buy the mansion?

 

 

 

Prof Simon Says:

 

No. Alex’s rights cannot be exercised in this case.

 

The right of first refusal goes under the condition that Alex is a sitting tenant and that the buyer is a third party. If the case is between Alex and a random Bob, Alex can exercise his right and buy the mansion under the same terms and conditions.

 

However, as the buyer is Jack’s wife, being a close relative, Alex has no choice but to take Jack’s offer and buy another mansion or leave for mansion when the lease expires.

 

Simon Says - Episode 13: Can a sitting tenant rights outweigh that of landlord’s spouse

 

 

For more about this or to contact Professor Simon Choi at www.acmeardent.comsimonhkchoi@163.com, +86 13823677853 or by WeChat: simonhkchoi. 

 

ACME Ardent's Simon Choi WeChat QR Code

 

"This article was originally written in Chinese by Mr Huanyu Li and rewritten into English by Simon Choi."

 

Simon Choi

About the Author: Professor Simon Choi

Prof Simon Choi, solicitor and linguist, is an international lawyer, qualified to practise law in England & Wales and in Hong Kong, China. Simon graduated from law schools of the Peking University, the University of London and the University of Hong Kong respectively, with an in-depth knowledge of Chinese laws and common laws and with more than 20 years experience in China practice and international trade, investment, finance, merger & acquisition. He is an adjunct professor of laws at the Zhongnan University of Economics and Law. Simon is the founding partner of Acme Ardent and can be reached at simonhkchoi@163.com or +86 13823677853.

FEATURED EVENTS & PROMOS See All

3rd Annual End of Summer Event (Welcome Back Party)

If You're New To Shenzhen, Returning From The Summer Holiday, Looking To Meet Some New People, And Or Want To Enjoy A Great Party, This Is The Event For You! Each year ShekouDaily hosts its popular Welcome Back event (a.k.a. "End of Summer Par


The G&D 12inch Burger Challenge!
The G&D 12inch Burger Challenge!

Starting August 4, George & Dragon introduces the Burger Challenge! Finish a 12" burger meal within 30 minutes and get it for f...

Happy Hour Every Day at X-TA-SEA from 3pm-9pm
Happy Hour Every Day at X-TA-SEA from 3pm-9pm

Happy Hour at X-TA-SEA Sports Bar & Restaurant inside the Minghua Cruise Ship in Sea World Get 50% OFF Mixed Drinks, Beer, Sof...